Discussion about this post

User's avatar
JoAnn Pullen, MD, HMDC's avatar

I truly believe that in order to get Medicare, you should have to fill out an advanced directive and have it on file on a national database accessible to All.

Peter M. Abraham, BSN, RN's avatar

Happy belated birthday!

Jim, in Kentucky, it is worse, with approximately 9% of adults having some kind of advance directive. And I'm not sure if you know this, Jim, but the medical living will can be written to encompass the 1990 Patient Self-Determination Act (PSDA), listing treatment and medication refusals that must be honored by any healthcare organization that receives money from Medicare or Medicaid, and when written to include treatment preferences can provide a foundation for a plan of care the healthcare team would use to avoid overtreatment and honoring the wishes of the patient.

I do advance care planning for a living, Jim. Most of them have you and others fill out four checkboxes - prolong life or not, artificial hydration and nutrition or not, antibiotics at the end or not, and then organ donation. Then they put the burden of value-based decisions on the healthcare surrogate, who often caves in under stress and pressure, letting the doctors do what they think is best -- COMPLETELY missing the point of having a value-based plan. Overtreatment still occurs.

My clients get a complete package in which the healthcare surrogate provides the healthcare team with a value-based medical living will and the associated paperwork, so they can spend time with the one they love and be available only if there's a lack of clarity in the directions.

I am hoping more follow, because this is an area that not only needs more people with advance care planning done, but more who focus on values vs. checkboxes.

No posts

Ready for more?